REAL INSIGHTS
› Mind
› Finding the Light in Seasonal Depression
Episode 60

Why Seasonal Depression Can Make Winter Feel So Much Harder

Diane N. Solomon, PhD, writes The Narrative Nurse Practitioner, a Psychology Today column on mental health and well-being. She joins Holly to talk about why winter can wear you down, and why light may be part of the answer.

What to Know About Light Therapy for Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD)

Seasonal depression, also called seasonal affective disorder or SAD, is depression that follows the calendar. It most often shows up in late fall or early winter, settles in through the darkest months, and eases in spring.

That pattern is exactly what makes it easy to miss. One hard winter looks like stress. Five in a row starts to look like your personality.

What Seasonal Depression Can Look Like

Diane N. Solomon, PhD, is a psychiatric nurse practitioner who spent more than thirty years caring for women. She describes a low mood that usually travels with physical changes: eating more, sleeping more or sleeping badly, and feeling slowed down. Anxiety often comes along too, and some of it can overlap with perimenopause.

One of the biggest clues, she says, is timing. If it arrives around the same time every year and lifts when the days get longer, that pattern is worth paying attention to.

Where Light Therapy Comes In

Natural light helps set the body's internal clock, and the darker months bring far less of it. Dr. Solomon's answer is bright light therapy, used the right way. In this episode, she walks through the small details that make the difference, from how close the light should be to what time of day to use it. Most of them, she says, are easy to get wrong and just as easy to fix.

You don't have to wait until you can't get out of bed.
Diane N. Solomon, PhD
Psychiatric nurse practitioner and Psychology Today writer
A note from Holly

Maybe You've Been Explaining It Away

When the days get short, you start to feel like a different woman.

You're more tired. Shorter with people. You want the pasta, not the walk. And you tell yourself it's the cold, or menopause, or just a busy time of year.

Dr. Solomon points to research estimating that about four in five people with seasonal affective disorder are women.

She's also clear that when something changes in you every winter, your body is trying to tell you something. And you deserve to be listened to.

Holly
Holly Osterman · Founder & host, Empart
A Closer Look

Questions Worth Asking Yourself

Seasonal depression can be hard to see from the inside, especially once you've gotten used to it. These questions are a way to step back and look at your own winter a little more honestly.

What month do I usually start feeling like this? And when does it lift?

What have I quietly stopped doing since the days got shorter?

When I'm worn out by five o'clock, what do I tell myself it is?

On the days I feel worst, what happened the day before? Too little sleep, a skipped lunch, another gray morning?

What would I be doing right now if I felt like myself?

About the guest

Diane N. Solomon, PhD

Psychiatric nurse practitioner and writer of The Narrative Nurse Practitioner at Psychology Today

Diane N. Solomon, PhD, is a psychiatric nurse practitioner and certified nurse-midwife who spent more than thirty years caring for women in rural, tribal, and urban Oregon. She writes The Narrative Nurse Practitioner for Psychology Today and is an adjunct professor at Oregon Health & Science University.

Dr. Solomon earned her PhD in nursing, with a focus on gerontology, from OHSU and her master's in nurse-midwifery from Yale. She specialized in women's mental health in her Portland psychiatric practice before closing it to write full time. Her work has also appeared in HuffPost, MedPage Today, Psychotherapy Networker, and Next Avenue, and she hosts the web series Women of a Certain Age.

Diane N. Solomon, PhD

You don't have to figure this out alone.

If this conversation made you want to ask better questions at your next appointment, or made you realize there's a lot you still want to understand about this stage of your life, you're exactly who this community was built for.

Full transcript

Read the full conversation

00:40 · Meet Diane N. Solomon, PhD

Holly: Diane N. Solomon, PhD, is a psychiatric nurse practitioner and the writer behind The Narrative Nurse Practitioner at Psychology Today.

She spent more than 30 years caring for women with a career that's crossed women's health, mental health, and aging. And today, she writes about those same issues in a way that makes complicated things feel a lot easier to understand.

So if every winter you find yourself wondering why you don't quite feel like you, this episode is for you.

Holly: Diane, welcome. I'm so happy to have you here today.

Dr. Solomon: Thank you. I'm so glad to be here.

01:20 · When the Winter Blues Become Something More

Holly: So you're a psychiatric nurse practitioner with a PhD, and you've spent more than 30 years caring for women and you're writing for them now.

And that's how I found you, through your writing for Psychology Today. One of the things that I'd love to talk to you about, and you wrote an article about this, was winter blues. When does feeling a little down because it's cold and dark outside become something that we might wanna start paying attention to?

Dr. Solomon: I was so happy when you contacted me because I love this topic so much, and it is something that so many people suffer from, and they don't know that they, there are some really great and simple things they can do.

02:07 · Why Seasonal Affective Disorder Is More Common in Women

Especially women, the first thing to know is that 80% of people that have seasonal affective disorder, like their symptoms are bad enough they could be clinically diagnosed with seasonal affective disorder, 80% of them are women.

And this does not stop at menopause.

That's the other thing I loved about you contacting me is that suddenly menopause is a big topic, like women who are going through menopause now, you know, kind of feel like it hasn't been talked about and they're inventing it. But I've worked with menopausal women for two, three decades, and so I'm so glad that it's being talked about more.

But I'm kind of like, really? People feel like this isn't talked about? I was always asking women how are they doing, are they having any symptoms, because perimenopause can definitely last up to 10 years with lots of symptoms and changes, and including exacerbations of PMS, it just keeps getting worse as we get older, or PMDD, and seasonal affective disorder.

So go ahead.

Holly: Oh, I was just gonna say, I was so surprised by that number though, 80%. That's, that's a big number.

Dr. Solomon: That is a big number, and if you think about who you know that says, "Gee, the weather's really bothering me. The gray's really..." It's not so much the cold, it's the gray, and at higher latitudes, it's the shortness of the days, so there's no daylight. I grew up in San Diego where, you know, the sun rises and sets pretty much the same time all year round, and I came to Portland to go to college, and the cold was unusual, the rain was unusual, and the gray especially, if you think about it, think about the cave. When we were in the cave, even if we were at a higher latitude, we went out of the cave and we always got, even if it wasn't sunlight, natural light.

And we need that natural light to entrain our circadian rhythms. It affects our mood. It affects our anxiety. It affects our sleep. It affects bipolar disorder in people that have bipolar. And seasonal affective disorder can be exacerbated in all those situations, and it can exacerbate all those situations.

It can screw up your sleep, your appetite, your mood, your anxiety, et cetera, et cetera.

05:23 · What Are the Symptoms of Seasonal Depression?

Holly: I live in Chicago and, it happens every year. Somewhere along the way, we don't see sunshine for days at a time, and you turn on the news and they're like, "Today is the eighth day without sunshine." And we wonder why all of us are sort of getting into this funk. What are some of the, the symptoms that you notice women experience during that time?

Dr. Solomon: Yeah, it's all those things I've said. It's a down mood. It's what we call vegetative symptoms, which is like eating more, feeling slower. It, we call it psychomotor slowing, like we just feel like we can't move as well or as easily. Problems with sleep, oversleeping, or having a weird sleep rhythm that, you know, delayed phase, can't go to sleep until really late, but then having a hard time getting up, or insomnia.

And anxiety too. You know, when I'm talking about women and psychiatric disorders, almost every psychiatric disorder that a woman has seems to be more complicated by anxiety than if a man has it.

06:51 · Does Seasonal Depression Come Back Every Year?

Holly: How important is the pattern? Because I know, and then I've talked to a lot of women who say that, starting now they, they notice that they start to feel a little low and, and it happens around the same time every year. But then come springtime they feel like themselves again.

Dr. Solomon: That is totally one of the biggest clues. So growing up in San Diego and coming to Portland when, yes, in September, October, the days start getting a lot of, a lot shorter, and they don't really get to a decent length in my view, until at least May. In my psychiatric practice, I would always tell women, "Start treating your seasonal affective disorder in October and do not stop until May."

07:46 · Is It Menopause or Seasonal Depression?

Holly: Well, I have one question before we get to it, only because I, I wanna make sure that I understand something first. Because as a woman in midlife, it can be a little bit hard, like you mentioned before, if we're already dealing with symptoms of menopause, right? And some of it is the same. You know, lack of focus, and eating weird, and also sleeping poorly. How do we even begin to sort out whether it could be hormonal, whether it could be seasonal, or maybe a little bit of both?

Dr. Solomon: Well, it probably is both because if you've had the seasonal changes since before you became perimenopausal, then it's probably getting worse as your hormones are being disrupted by perimenopause. There seems to be increased sensitivity often to those changes. If you've never felt seasonal affective disorder before, a lot of your symptoms may be perimenopausal and not seasonal affective disorder, and a real way to tell is whether it's cyclical.

With seasonal affective disorder, you're gonna have the symptoms all month long or however, you know, in perimenopause, your periods may get closer together. Well, they do get closer together, and then they get farther apart.

And in seasonal affective disorder, you might have an exacerbation right before your period, but you're going to have the symptoms pretty much all the time to some level in those dark months.

09:38 · How Light Therapy Works for SAD

I'll talk about the treatment now if you want. It's very effective. It's very easy. It's very cost-effective, and people don't do it the right way or give it a chance, and so they really lose out.

So here is the first thing. You have to get a light, and you can get one on Amazon, although the prices often at this time of year are higher, and cheaper in the spring. But you can get one for, like, $30. And they used to be huge, but now you can get a small light, and that's what I recommend. Here are the things you need to know about it.

It needs to have what's called 10,000 lux, and it should say that right there on the box or the website or what have you. And it needs to be portable, because you need to be able to use it in the morning wherever you are.

I don't care when in the morning, it needs to be before noon. So what I do is put it on the counter, I'm so short, so, a lot of people have to put it on a box, in my bathroom.

So as soon as I get up in the morning, it's on until I have brushed my teeth, I come back and shower, I come back and get dressed, if I put any makeup on. It's on that whole time, when I'm coming, going. And it needs to be 12 to 18 inches from your face. If it's farther than that, it's not gonna work. And so the, all, so I haven't even told you really how to use it, but there's a bunch of ways already people don't do it.

They don't use it every day. You really need to use it at least five days a week. They don't use it close enough to their face, and they don't have a light box that's 10,000 lux. So all those things are gonna make it not work. Some of them have settings, mild, medium, high, and you can see what works for you.

If you're a breakfast eater, you can put it right there at the table when you're scrolling your phone. You don't have to look at it. It just needs to be shining on your face.

And you should usually have it for about half an hour, but you'll play with it. You might be able to get away with 20 minutes, 10 minutes on the high setting might be enough for you. You're going to know within a few days.

Your energy's gonna be better. You're gonna feel more upbeat. And if you're using it in the morning in the right way, you might even notice that quickly improvement in your sleep or your wind down at night. There's only one side effect that you need to worry about with light therapy, it's called BLT or bright light therapy, and that is people who have bipolar disorder, and if you get too much light, if you leave it on too long and forget, if you have bipolar disorder, it may make you feel a little manic, but that goes away. And if you don't have bipolar disorder, it may, if you use it too long or too high, it may make you feel a little agitated or anxious that day.

But again, that goes away generally within a few hours. And all you have to do then is go, "Oh, okay, that was too long or too high. I'm gonna cut down the minutes."

13:52 · How Often Should You Use a Light Box?

Holly: And using it every day, is it, does it build on itself? Is that why it's so important to do it consistently?

Dr. Solomon: That, there's a lot of reasons. First of all, it works, some people even say the first day. So you need to use it every day because it's not, just, it kind of is like a medication. It wears off, and if you're back to the gloom and the gray, it, it doesn't last much longer than 24 hours. But also, if you're retraining your sleep clock, it needs that consistency, and yes, that building up, and then you sleep better one night, and then you use the light again, and you sleep better the next night.

Instead of one night it's good, and one night it's gone. It's a cumulative effect.

Holly: It seems like such a simple thing, and I think those are always the things that we tend to push back against. Like, feeling better should be more challenging. So I, I'm glad that we're talking about it. And I, I believe you also mentioned that it helps not just to, with the, for women, not just with the seasonal, depression, but also with, you know, some of the hormonal challenges that...

Dr. Solomon: Yes, exactly. Because we are creatures, we are animals that were evolved to depend on light, again, even if it's not sun shining, natural light outside to train our hormones, train our sleep cycle. So yes, it can really help with some of the hormonal mood swings and maybe even the hormonal swings of perimenopause, which are very erratic.

Holly: So it, it wouldn't hurt to use it, not just, you know, when you're starting to feel blue. So now we're getting into the, those months where we are more aware of what's going on outside, and we don't see the sun as often. So your advice is almost, you'll use it or put it somewhere where you're gonna use it, like you said, where you're brushing your teeth or you're eating your breakfast, to make it a part of your daily routine.

Dr. Solomon: Yes, or on your bedside table when you first wake up and you're scrolling your phone. Just make sure it's close enough to your face. You know, a lot of people think, "Well, I put it on my bedside table and I used it every day for a week and it didn't work. I put it away." Well, it didn't work 'cause it wasn't close enough to their face.

And to your prior question, yes, if you're mildly depressed and it has nothing to do with seasonal affective disorder, or anxious, or having a problem with insomnia, yes, try it. There is really no downside. You know, it's not a pharmaceutical, which I think is why it hasn't become so popular. I think, it's not that it's easy and that's why people don't use it, it's that they have to get into a groove.

It's a habit, and people sometimes have trouble with habits. Think of how hard it is to get people to exercise. People need to exercise too, but this is much easier than trying to get the habit of exercise. And literally, if you try it for two weeks in the right way, I rarely, rarely hear people saying, "No, it didn't work for me."

17:51 · What Else Helps With Seasonal Affective Disorder?

Holly: Are there any other things that you can recommend for seasonal affective disorder? Including the light therapy, but is there anything else?

Dr. Solomon: Getting outside in morning light. And when I say morning light and use the light box in the morning, it's because if you use it in the afternoon, generally, unless, except in very rare cases, there are some people that get seasonal affective disorder in reverse, like they do worse in summer. But it's very rare.

I've seen it in people with bipolar disorder more than in others.

So basically for everyone, I say morning light, morning light therapy, and sleep hygiene. I really, you know, again, with the cave, in the winter when it's darker outside earlier, we are not meant to be up late. And I think, another really little-known but highly effective helper with sleep and mood and staying in a regular rhythm, in the dark months especially, is no bright light after sunset.

Obviously, we're gonna be eating or, you know, in our bedroom winding down, whatever. Put a bedside lamp, no overhead light. That messes with your sleep. And even when we talk about all the sleep hygiene things like, you know, no screens a couple hours before bed and have a wind-down ritual and do something calming before bed, we don't mention no bright light, and that is really important too, because the bright light goes into our eyes to our brains, and that's why no screen time.

We also don't want bright overhead light.

Holly: Do you have a routine that you use to help yourself go to sleep every night?

Dr. Solomon: I absolutely do, and I'm, I, I feel kind of bad about it because I'm blessed with being a person who likes routine, and I know for very, so many people, it's very hard to have a routine. But, I like to settle down pretty early, maybe by 8:00 PM. I am a reader, so I will read in bed for an hour, hour and a half, maybe even two hours, and then turn the lights out and sometimes do, Insight Timer.

I'm not paid by them, but I think it's the absolute greatest, meditation and self, personal development app, out there. I have a 10-minute meditation that I might play while I'm falling asleep.

Holly: Do you keep your phone by your bed or do you...

Dr. Solomon: I do keep my phone by my bed, and, when people call me when I'm trying to do my quiet hour or hours at bedtime, I will sometimes not answer. If it's my kids, I'm like, "I'm in my quiet time," and they're like, "Okay, talk to you later." Yes, so I do keep it by my bed, 'cause I look at it in the morning.

I'm, you know, that's the other thing I feel bad about. I'm pretty disciplined about use of my phone, and I know that isn't easy for everyone, or lots of people. And if that was difficult for me, I think I would keep it across the room or somewhere else.

22:11 · Is It Okay to Go to Bed Early in Winter?

Holly: You had mentioned, with seasonal affective disorder that we wanna go to bed early. Like, how early is too early? It's dark by 5:00, and you, your brain already starts thinking, "Can I go to bed yet?"

Dr. Solomon: Have you tried to go to bed at five o'clock?

Holly: Sometimes I want to, but no. No, I haven't.

But your mind thinks that, and it's cold and gloomy outside, and you just wanna wrap yourself in a blanket and, curl up.

Dr. Solomon: I asked you that because I'm really curious if you have done it, when did you wake up, and did you go to sleep? Because I think that if you want to curl up and lay down at 5:00, I mean, it would be bad to take a nap then, but if you're sleep deprived and you wanna, every, you know, once a month you sleep from 6:00 PM to 5:00 or 6:00 AM, I think that's fine.

And I think most people, if they lay down at 5:00 after a long day, they might close their eyes for a little while, but they probably would not go to sleep. And it's, it is a time of year where our bodies are slower, so it's okay, again, listening to ourselves, to rest, you know? And rest does not necessarily mean sleep.

So, if you wanna take a half an hour to rest and either close your eyes or honestly, you know, watch something mindless for half an hour, a comedy or something you've seen a million times, or lay there wrapped in a blanket listening to a podcast or a book on tape, that is a great way to rest. And then you can say, "Okay, now I'll get up, get something to eat, and stay up until 8:00."

24:18 · When to Talk to a Doctor About Winter Depression

Holly: Yes. Yes. Which is probably the wiser thing to do. At what point should a woman stop trying to figure this out on her own and either talk to a doctor or a mental health professional?

Dr. Solomon: That is such a great question. Thank you for asking. Basically, with every psychiatric disorder, it's a spectrum. How bad is it? Do you feel down or blue for a day or do you clinically have major depressive disorder? Basically, the cutoff that tells us, I mean, we measure, we ask about all the different symptoms, et cetera, but if it is interfering with your functioning, you deserve someone else's help.

I mean, you could try light therapy and see if that does everything you need, but if it's interfering with your functioning, if you're not enjoying what you usually enjoy, if you're not sleeping well, if you're calling in late to work or calling off taking care of kids or grandkids or what have you, if you find it difficult to get out of the house or you're just too anxious to do the things that make your life your life, that is a problem.

And don't, you know, you don't have to wait until you can't get out of bed. It's that it's interfering with your normal functioning. That is not a super high bar. And again, women need to know when they don't feel like themselves that they deserve to reach out for help.

Holly: Well, for the woman who has spent years telling herself, "I just don't do winter very well," what do you want her to know?

Dr. Solomon: I want her to know that she deserves a vacation in a sunny climate. And I also want her to know if that isn't accessible or it is, that light therapy can be a game changer, and I would try light therapy for two weeks. With the interfering with functioning question, if it's going on for two weeks more days than not, I would also reach out for help.

And I also would really want her to know that she is not alone, and there should not be a stigma associated with this. Again, we're animals, and we have these seasonal cycles, and her body is trying to tell her something, and she deserves to be listened to.

27:23 · How a Mood Chart Can Help You Spot the Pattern

Holly: Would you encourage her to keep a log of how she's feeling?

Dr. Solomon: Oh, golly. I wish everybody would have asked me that question because, because it is so instructive. Talk about, okay, PMS, perimenopause, seasonal affective disorder. I would try so many times to get women to do what's called a menstrual chart.

There are a lot of apps now, but I, I do love a pen and paper menstrual mood chart.

You can just Google it, and a lot of them will come up. You can find one that you like, and even if you're not menstruating anymore, it's a month, so it'll show you the months. And you can write in, you know, it measures sleep and any medications you're taking, and alcohol and exercise and social activity, and when you woke up and when you went to bed, and anything else you want to measure there.

Like, did you have a fight with your spouse or good friend, or did your pet get sick, or... And after two months, you know, it's, it's always been really hard for me to convince women to do this, but if they do it, after two months, what they learn about, even after a month, but really after two months, they're generally astounded by what they learn about themselves, and knowledge is power.

And then they can say, "Okay, these days I can see because of this I didn't do well. Next time this happens," whether it's rain or gloomy dark or, you know, that interpersonal conflict or missing lunch too many days in a row or not getting enough sleep, "when this happens, I know to take care the next day," or at least to know the next day if I'm feeling blue or anxious, I can tell myself, "Okay, it's because of PMS or it's because I had one too many drinks or I didn't get enough sleep, and I know it's gonna be better tomorrow."

That is so much more powerful than saying, "I feel awful, and I don't know why."

Holly: Mm-hmm. Exactly. I couldn't agree with you more. I, I think so much could get lost when we just think about our day as opposed to actually writing it down, and some of those details do matter.

Dr. Solomon: Absolutely.

30:13 · Where to Follow Dr. Solomon's Work

Holly: Before I let you go though, is there anything that you've got going on, where's the best place that we could find you and follow along with your writing?

Dr. Solomon: Yes, thank you. I am on Psychology Today. I post an article every couple weeks. You can Google my name and Psychology Today. I'm on Instagram as Dr. Diane Solomon. I'm also on LinkedIn, and I've been recording, it hasn't released that yet, a web series where I interview amazing women that I know called Women of a Certain Age.

And on Instagram and LinkedIn, that will be coming up soon. So I'm really excited about that because I feel like women at our age, traditionally, our place in society, part of it is to impart our wisdom and our knowledge, and there aren't that very many ways or platforms for us to do that. And younger people actually can really benefit from our wisdom, but a lot of them are in echo chambers of 30-somethings, and they wanna know where to find that, you know, lived experience and wisdom.

So I'm really excited about it. Women of a Certain Age.

Holly: Well, we'll keep, definitely keep our eyes open for that. And we do have a lot of wisdom, I would agree with you.

So, thank you today for stopping by and sharing your wisdom, and hopefully this is something that we can take with us, and as the months progress and in winter is upon us, that we've got a few tools to use.

Dr. Solomon: Exactly. And thank you, Holly. Your show is fantastic, and I'm really honored to be here and share whatever I know. Thank you.